From: Larson, Rod
Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2008 7:00
AM
To: Duemke, Roger
Subject: IBST Status
Roger,
Going pretty well.
The language barrier is not good, but the guy that left the rep came in today
and saved my ass. Got thru tuning the table and the customer did well. The
translation finally took about the same time as it did for me to talk. Before it
took about 10x longer....
Bought a PC today
for $437. Not bad eh? It is an HP desktop. Looks better than those small shrimpy
ones...and it is faster w/ more memory and has DVD R/W.
Should finish w/
adaptive control tomorrow. I am going to run max performance tomorrow afternoon
and hope that does it for everyone.
It IS very likely
that I will have to return in a few months to answer questions and give more
training. These guys are starting from ground zero (no test experience and no
hydraulics experience). I can probably connect a future trip w/ a trip to Korea,
Japan or Taiwan after the 1st of the year. I can probably stuff it in some other
account.....
There are some
problems w/ the system that you, as a PE should know about. Do NOT take this
criticism personally cuz you have had not much experience in this area before.
The customer can maybe live with these, but some earthquakes will give them
trouble. Kobe cannot run on the system because it IS within the capability of
the table but there is NOT enough accumulation. Typically, the performance curve
is not enough. Kusner has a sizer that puts out the recommended accumulator
sizing given a pump size and actuators. From my measurements, there is no
more than just flow averaging accumulators on this system. In addition, the
filtration is compromised without a kidney loop constantly filtering the oil. A
seismic system spends a great deal of time NOT flowing very much oil, even
during tuning. I have had to run VERY large sine waves a few times to help clean
things up..... also dither around 1-2 volts. Also, the heat exchanger
does not seem big enough to handle tropical climates. Today, the ambient
temperature was 38C and that caused us to get a little hot. When we were running
hard the temp went over 55C. When the oil goes over 50C, the 3-stage servovalves
tend to squawk and screech at you. Yesterday we went all the way to overtemp at
65C cuz we ran out of water in the tower. Filled up today and we managed around
50C worst case. The controller has NO A/Ds or D/As in it. This makes it
impossible to put in any analog signal from customer conditioners to acquire w/
the system data. Also, no outputs means he cannot use his National Instruments
Data Acquisition system to record our system stuff along w/ his signals to time
correlate them.....
Brad has one bug
left in the system. He does not have a X or Y DOF displacement signal output.
The position he shows contains the angle cross-coupling in it. That is ok for
the actuator displacement, but NOT for the DOF displacement. Cross-coupling
compensation should not be shown in DOF. For example, if you stroke X a total of
+/-250 mm, the Y actuator moves 12 mm. Brad shows the Y DOF moving 12 mm instead
of ZERO as it should. I will try to get this fixed by tomorrow if I can. It is
not a show-stopper, just embarrassing...
Other than that Mrs.
Lincoln, how did you like the play?? NO...it has not been bad at
all. The system is actually a sweetheart and runs VERY well. I really like those
bearings. Just have to warn the customer not to run 30Hz sine waves in one place
for an hour.....just wish we had some accumulators.....customer is also very
understanding and pretty nice people.
Rod